Best Pizza Places on Siesta Key

There’s no stretch in saying that the U.S. loves pizza.  94% of all Americans admit to eating pizza regularly.  In fact, Americans eat approximately 100 acres of pizza each day – that’s about 350 slices every second.  It makes sense that people on vacation will look to indulge in some pizza as well.  Luckily, Siesta Key has some great places to satisfy those pizza urges.  Here are the best pizza places on Siesta Key.

Ripfire Pizza and BBQ

5218 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 313-7511

If you want pizza with fresh ingredients, Ripfire is your place.  They make everything in-house, source local veggies, and use only the best meats.  They use fresh Grande Mozzarella on their signature Margherita and a blend of Mozzarella and Provolone on all of their customizable pizzas.  Another popular pie is their smoked chicken pizza.

Flavios Brick Oven & Bar

5239 Ocean Blvd., Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 349-0995

Flavios serves brick-oven pizza and classic Italian cuisine.  It prides itself on welcoming ambiance and outstanding service.  They have a very robust menu but the pizza keeps a lot of locals and tourists coming back year after year.  They also have outdoor dining available.

Clayton’s Siesta Grille

1256 Old Stickney Point Road, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 349-2800

While not actually a pizzeria, they do serve up a pie that you won’t soon forget.  Their service is excellent as well.  They take pride in serving fresh ingredients and friendly, knowledgeable staff.  Their pizza selection may not be the biggest, but if you like brick oven pizza, you’ll love what they offer.

Il Panificio Pizzeria

215 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key, FL 34242

(941) 800-5570

Sicilian pizza, brick oven pizza, gluten-free pizza, thick crust pizza, veggie pizza and more – Il Panificio does it all.  Their base pizza is an authentic Italian thin crust prepared with homemade dough and the finest cheese, sauce, and ingredients they can source.  Like many on this list, they also offer appetizers, beer, wine, and assorted desserts.

When those pizza cravings kick in, rest assured that Siesta Key has a good variety of pizza places to choose from.  From brick oven to New York style to pizza by the slice, you’ll find your favorites here, most likely within walking distance from The Inn on Siesta Key.

Our Reviews

yelp logo
facebook logo
tripadvisor logo
Google logo