About Us

The Cottage was originally built in 1936 and is one of the oldest homes on the Siesta Key. The Cottage actually predates Beach Road when the Inn was beachfront property.

The Inn is conveniently located on Siesta Key Beach, access #9, and its guests enjoy beach access right across the road. Siesta Village is also just a 5-minute walk from the Inn.

Our Staff

Paige & Gabe

Originally from Michigan, Paige Hartmann moved to Siesta Key in 1991 and has been in the vacation rental business ever since. Here, she raised her two boys, Nate and Gabe, and grew her business. Enjoying giving personalized service to her guests, Paige decided to concentrate on her favorite piece of property, which became the Inn on Siesta Key.

Paige loves being involved in the community and is a Past Chair of the Siesta Key Chamber of Commerce and a Past Chair of Visit Sarasota County. She was a long-standing board member and past chair of CYD (Community Youth Development). She also enjoys nature, especially the wildlife that is found on Siesta Key.

In 2012, Gabe Hartmann became a partner with his mother and adds tremendous renovation skills. With his contributions, the Inn on Siesta Key has been given a fresh look which has thrilled longtime guests. He is also a knowledgeable fisherman. Paige and Gabe both share the same philosophy about customer service and making every guest feel welcomed and relaxed.


Our Reviews

yelp logo
facebook logo
tripadvisor logo
Google logo